Make your life a dream, and a dream, a reality.Antoine de Saint-Exupéry
The Cultural and Creative Industries
In order to really understand my educational background (why did I choose to study at Paris 1 Sorbonne and LSE?) and my career choices made in the last years and detailed in the previous pages, this (very long) article adresses the following issues:
- an introduction on the creative industries and globalization
- the definitions of the cultural and creative industries
- the economy of the cultural and creative industries
- the French cultural and creative industries
- the theory of the cultural and creative industries
- a conclusion on the creative industries and digitalization
1/6 – Introduction: the Creative Industries and Globalization
As I have always been fond of arts, culture, media and technology, I decided to specialize in the creative industries (also called the creative economy or more traditionally the cultural industries, especially in Continental Europe). Both France and Europe have global leaders in these competitive markets. The cultural and creative industries (CCIs) combine the creation (often by artists, authors or designers), production (often by companies) and distribution (often by multinationals) of goods and services that are cultural in nature and usually protected by artistic and intellectual property rights (IPR). The CCIs have an « irreducible core » concerned with « the exchange of finance for rights in intellectual property » (Lash and Urry, 1994). More than any other industries, the CCIs have been facing two important challenges in the 1990s and 2000s: the emergence of disruptive information and communication technologies (ICTs) and globalization.
After my Law, Economics, Management and Strategy studies at the Sorbonne, I decided to study in the country that actively promoted the term and the concept of the « creative industries », the United Kingdom, the political economy of communication and the socio-economics of the cultural and creative industries, as well as globalization empowered by media and ICTs: from the telegraph, created by Guillaume Amontons (the 1690 optical telegraph) and Claude Chappe (the 1791 semaphore system), the first telecom entrepreneur in history who built the world’s first national telecommunications network in France, and cinema, invented by Auguste and Louis Lumière (the cinematrograph of 1895), and motion pictures made by filmmakers like Georges Méliès and produced, distributed and marketed by the world’s oldest film companies Gaumont (1895) and Pathé (1896), to digital globalization nowadays. And more precisely, I decided to study at the world’s best university for the study of media and globalization, the London School of Economics and Political Science (LSE) – the school of Anthony Giddens, former LSE director, British Emeritus Professor of Sociology and Global Studies (i.e., the pluridisciplinary study of globalization), the fifth most-referenced author of books in the humanities around the world (Giddens was ranked second among living scholars in 2007) and the inventor of the « Third Way » popularized by Tony Blair in the UK and by Bill Clinton in the US. Other prominent scholars of Globalization (from the fields of Sociology, Economics, Political Science, International Relations,…), famous all around the world, held academic positions at the LSE, for example: Ulrich Beck, Daniele Archibugi, David Held, Saskia Sassen, Centennial Visiting Professor of Political Economy at the LSE Department of Sociology, who coined the term « global city », and Terhi Rantanen, author of « The Media and Globalization » (SAGE, 2004), founding editor of the international journal Global Media and Communication and founding director of the unique MSc/MA Double Degree in Global Media and Communications (LSE with USC, Fudan and UCT).
2/6 – Definitions of the Cultural and Creative Industries
For UNESCO (the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization headquartered in Paris), »The UK is widely recognised as having played a groundbreaking role in developing these analytical models » of the creative industries since 1998.
The Department for Culture, Media and Sport (DCMS) of the United Kingdom Government defined in 2001 the creative industries as follows: « Those industries which have their origin in individual creativity, skill and talent and which have a potential for wealth and job creation through the generation and exploitation of intellectual property. » The United Kingdom Prime Minister’s Strategy Unit and GLA Economics (the Greater London Authority’s economic research unit), among others, have concluded that the creative industries are now even more important than financial services to the London economy!
According to UNESCO‘s « Understanding Creative Industries« :
« The term cultural industries refers to industries which combine the creation, production and commercialization of creative contents which are intangible and cultural in nature. The contents are typically protected by copyright and they can take the form of a good or a service. Cultural industries generally include printing, publishing and multimedia, audiovisual, phonographic and cinematographic productions as well as crafts and design. »
« The term creative industries encompasses a broader range of activities which include the cultural industries plus all cultural or artistic production, whether live or produced as an individual unit. The creative industries are those in which the product or service contains a substantial element of artistic or creative endeavour and include activities such as architecture and advertising. »
As of 2015, the UK makes a clear difference between the Creative Economy and the Creative Industries (the latter is defined as a subset of the former) and recognizes officially nine sectors being part of the Creative Industries:
- Advertising and marketing
- Design: product, graphic and fashion design
- Film, TV, video, radio and photography
- IT, software and computer services
- Museums, galleries and libraries
- Music, performing and visual arts
For more information about the definition of the CCIs on wikipedia, from an academic point of view:
- The concept of « culture industry » (« kulturindustrie ») was first coined in 1944 by the German sociologists and critical theorists from the Frankfurt School Theodor Adorno and Mark Horkheimer in their critical book towards the cultural industry « Dialectic of Enlightenment« .
For more information about the definition of the CCIs on wikipedia, from a business point of view:
3/6 – Economy of the Cultural and Creative Industries
According to the official study conducted for the first time in Europe’s history by EY (ex-Ernst & Young) and published in December 2014, « Creating Growth: Measuring cultural and creative markets in the EU« , the Cultural and Creative Industries represent in Europe:
- € 535.9 billion in turnover i.e. 4.2% of Europe’s GDP – € 74.6 billion only in France
- 7.1 million jobs i.e. 3.3% of the EU’s working population (third-largest employer, employ over 5 times as many Europeans as the telecommunications industry) – 1.2 million jobs only in France
They include (> 2012 turnover in the EU):
- Visual Arts (Design, Fashion*, Photography, Museums,…) > € 127.6 billion
- Publishing* (Books, Newspapers, Magazines,…) > € 107.1 billion
- Advertising* > € 93 billion
- Television* > € 90 billion
- Architecture > € 36.2 billion
- Performing Arts (Concerts*, Festivals,…) > € 31.9 billion
- Music* > € 25.3 billion
- Film > € 17.3 billion
- Video Games (computer games, phone and online gaming,…) > € 16 billion
- Radio* > € 10.4 billion
Also included in the CCIs sometimes:
- Libraries, Electronic Publishing and Softwares*
- Education*, Research and Development
- Cultural Tourism* and Gastronomy
- Sports and Outdoor Activities
*At one point in my life, I have worked in these 10 sectors of the cultural and creative industries
Additional resources about the Cultural and Creative Industries:
- The United Kingdom Creative Economy and Creative Industries, the foundational DCMS Creative Industries Mapping Documents (of April 1998 and April 2001) and the DCMS Creative Industries Economic Estimates (January 2015)
- In the 2010 Cultural and Creative Economy series of the British Council, « Mapping the Creative Industries: A Tool Kit«
- On the OECD’s website, « Key role of cultural and creative industries in the economy » written by a director of UNESCO
- The European Union Commission, « Supporting cultural and creative industries«
- The 2014 ECBN’s manifesto for internationalisation: « ACCESS: A Manifesto for Growth in Europe’s Cultural and Creative Industries » and the 2015 ECBN’s manifesto: « The Cultural and Creative Industries in Europe » by the European Creative Business Network
For more information about the European and Global Ernst & Young studies realized in 2014 and then in 2015 :
- The executive summary of the 2014 study on EY’s website commissioned by GESAC (European Grouping of Societies of Authors).
- The 2014 complete study (PDF file) in French « Les secteurs culturels et créatifs européens, générateurs de croissance » and in English « Creating Growth: Measuring cultural and creative markets in the EU » on EY’s website commissioned by GESAC.
- The executive summary of the 2015 study commissioned by CISAC (the International Confederation of Societies of Authors and Composers) and UNESCO.
- The complete results of the 2015 study (PDF file) « Cultural Times:The First Global Map of Cultural and Creative Industries » are available on EY’s website, UNESCO’s website or on the dedicated website of CISAC presenting the study, World Creative. For the first time, this survey quantifies the global economic and social contribution of this important sector. The study analyzes 11 CCIs: advertising, architecture, books, gaming, movies, music, newspapers/magazines, performing arts, radio, television and visual arts.
4/6 – The French Cultural and Creative Industries
Along with the French Ministry of Culture and Communication, the French Ministry of Foreign Affairs supports the Cultural and creative industries in France.
EY was the first to publish a comprehensive economic study on the Cultural and Creative Industries in France in November 2013 in French « 1er panorama des industries culturelles et créatives en France. Au coeur du rayonnement et de la compétitivité de la France » and in English « First overview of Cultural and Creative Industries. At the heart of France’s Influence and Competitiveness » in partnership with the main professional associations and societies of Culture and Creation in France under the patronage of the French Government and then again in October 2015 « Création sous tension – 2e panorama de l’économie de la culture et de la création en France« .
On the EY’s website dedicated to the French CCIs, France Creative, you can find a short executive summary in English on the French Cultural and Creative Industries stating that « One of France’s centres of excellence, the cultural and creative industries account for 4% of GDP, which puts France second among the G8 countries just behind the USA. Their development stands for critical soft power with high geostrategic stakes. The new forms of creation and distributions of their goods and services give the French cultural industries important leverage for growth. » and that « France has the largest music publishing company in the world (Universal Music Group), one of the international leaders in web-based music streaming services (Deezer), the second largest publishing group on the worldwide scene (Hachette), and the third video game publisher (Ubisoft). France ranks third in the world as cinema producer and second only to the US as exporter; is the third international editor of animation films. The country has the first European TV broadcaster (TF1), the second most broadcasted musical repertoire in the world just after the Anglo-American repertoire. »
The European Cultural and Creative Industries Alliance, ECCIA, is composed of the five national European luxury good organizations – Circulo Fortuny (Spain), Fondazione Altagamma (Italy), Meisterkreis (Germany), Walpole (United Kingdom) and of course, the prestigious Comité Colbert for France with members such as:
- Haute Couture and Fashion brands – Lanvin (1889), Chanel (1912), Lacoste (1933), Pierre Balmain (1945), Céline (1945), Christian Dior Couture (1947), Chloé (1952), Givenchy (1952), Yves Saint Laurent (1962),…
- Leather Goods brands – Hermès (1837), Berluti (1895), Louis Vuitton (1854), Longchamp (1948),…
- Fragrance and Cosmetic brands – Guerlain (1828), Caron (1904), Parfums Chanel (1924), Rochas (1925), Lancôme/L’Oréal Produits de Luxe (1935), Parfums Christian Dior (1948), Parfums Hermès (1948), Parfums Givenchy (1957), Yves Saint Laurent Parfums (1962),…
- Jewelry and Crystal brands – Baccarat (1764), Breguet (1775), Cartier (1847), Boucheron (1858), Van Cleef & Arpels (1906),…
- Wine and Spirits brands – Château d’Yquem (1593), Veuve Clicquot Ponsardin (1772), Champagne Bollinger (1829), Château Cheval Blanc (1832), Champagne Krug (1843), Château Lafite-Rothschild (1855),…
- Gastronomy brands – Dalloyau (1682), Hédiard (1854), Lenôtre (1957), La Maison du Chocolat (1977), Pierre Hermé (1996), Alain Ducasse au Plaza Athénée (2000), L’Atelier de Joël Robuchon Étoile (2010),…
- Hospitality brands – Le Meurice (1835), Le Ritz (1898), Le Plaza Athénée (1911), Le Bristol (1924), Le George V (1928),…
- Cultural institutions – La Sorbonne (1257), Château de Versailles (1661), Villa Médicis (1666), Opéra National de Paris (1669), Comédie Française (1680), Musée du Louvre (1793), Les Arts Décoratifs (1882), IRCAM (1976), Musée d’Orsay (1986),…
5/6 – Theory of the Cultural and Creative Industries
The contributions of the scholars and alumni of both the London School of Economics and Political Science (LSE) and the University of Paris I Panthéon-Sorbonne (Paris 1) to the transdisciplinary field of the cultural and creative industries (including media sociology, media economics, media regulation and media management) have been foundational, essential and paramount since the 1970’s.
As early as 1982, Daniel Sabatier created at Paris 1 the world’s first degree in Media Law, Media Economics and Media Management (DESS Communication Audiovisuelle > DESS Droit et Administration de l’Audiovisuel > Master 2 Droit, Economie et Gestion de l’Audiovisuel). While the first course in Media Management in the UK appeared at the University of Stirling only in 1993.
At LSE, Terhi Rantanen created the world’s first degree in Media and Globalization in partnership with other top communication schools:
USC (University of Southern California) in 2000, Fudan University (Shanghai) in 2007 and UCT (University of Cape Town) in 2017.
I have had a passion for media and entertainment (comic books, music, radio, cinema, television and video games) since middle school. That is why it was my dream to study at Paris 1 and LSE…
Here is the list of the influential academics of the cultural and creative industries who inspired me the most (informal literature review):
- Marshall McLuhan (University of Toronto), Canadian Professor of English and author of pioneering books in popular culture, cultural studies, communication theory and media ecology: « The Mechanical Bride: Folklore of Industrial Man » (1951), « The Gutenberg Galaxy: The Making of Typographic Man » (1962) and « Understanding Media: The Extensions of Man » (1964). McLuhan is known for coining the expressions « the medium is the message », « hot » and « cool » media, the « global village », and for predicting the World Wide Web almost thirty years before it was invented. McLuhan‘s pioneering work is viewed as one of the cornerstones of Media Studies.
- Henri Mercillon (Université de Paris I Panthéon-Sorbonne), French Professor Emeritus of Economics, former director of the Centre d’Economie de l’Information de Paris 1/Sorbonne Center for the Information Economy, author of « Cinéma et Monopoles. Le Cinéma aux Etats-Unis : Etude Economique » (1952), « Industrie culturelle et littérature économique » (1963), « Economie de l’information » (1966-1967), « Economie des moyens d’information » (1967), « Monopoles de la connaissance et concurrence des moyens d’informations » (in « La Monnaie et l’économie de notre temps: mélanges en l’honneur du professeur Émile James », 1974), « Le Secteur commercial de la radio-diffusion d’État française : éléments d’une problématique socio-économique » (in « Mélanges offerts à Henri Guitton : le temps en économie, les mathématiques et l’économie, recherches pluridisciplinaires », 1977), « Les musées: institutions à but non lucratif dans l’économie marchande » (1977), « Le cinéma : entre l’art et l’argent » (préface, Pierre-Jean Benghozi, 1989) and editor of « O.R.T.F., l’agonie du monopole? La problématique de la télévision française durant la décennie soixante-dix » (1973) – the minutes of the historical pluridisciplinary symposium on French Television that Mercillon organized at the Sorbonne on October 10th 1972 gathering together the most prominent French academics: François Luchaire (co-founder of the University of Paris 1 Panthéon-Sorbonne), Fernand Terrou (former director of the French Press Institute of the University of Paris founded in 1937 who took part in the drafting of the Declaration of Press Rights of San Francisco in 1948 and who supported, with UNESCO, the establishment of the International Association for Studies and Research on Information and Communication in 1957) and the dean Claude-Albert Colliard (father of the former President of the University of Paris 1 Panthéon-Sorbonne, Jean-Claude Colliard); experienced French politicians: Olivier Giscard d’Estaing (co-founder of INSEAD), Joseph Rovan, Georges Fillioud, Alain Griotteray and André Diligent; famous French journalists of the press: Jean-François Revel, René Andrieu, Georges Suffert, Pierre Viansson-Ponté and Jean Diwo; and French top media executives of radio and TV programming and media professionals of radio and TV production: Jean d’Arcy (surprisingly anticipating very accurately the arrival of the Internet, and its future uses, during a French TV interview in 1969), Jean Frydman, Alain de Sédouy and André Harris. Following this symposium, the ORTF, French equivalent of the BBC, was dissolved in 1974 and replaced by TF1, France Télévisions, Radio France, INA, TDF and SFP.
I consider Mercillon as the first scholar of Cultural Economics in the world. Henri Mercillon was a Professor at the University of Paris in 1967-1970, Professor at the University of Paris 1 Panthéon-Sorbonne from 1970, Professor Emeritus at Paris 1 from 1992 until his death in 2011. In the 1960s-1970s, he popularized in France the works of McLuhan, Kalistratov, Conant, and of academics from other countries as well, for a truly global approach of the Economics of Arts, Culture and Communication (artworks, literature, theatre, museums, opera, music, press, radio, cinema, television).
A disciple of the prominent economist Henri Guitton (Université de Paris I Panthéon-Sorbonne), Henri Mercillon first gained academic recognition after his trip to the USA and the publication of his thesis on the Economics of Cinema (1952) as a book translated in different languages (1953). He was a friend of Jean Domarchi (a scholar of Economics, Philosophy and Cinema and film critic) and Jean-Claude Casanova (a famous economist and former president of the Fondation nationale des sciences politiques) that he both met at the Law Faculty of Dijon where Henri Mercillon started his university career (historically, courses of Economics were taught in Law Faculties in France prior to 1970).
Moreover, Mercillon also played a leading role in the establishment of the department of Business Administration and Management at the Sorbonne in 1971. The University of Paris 1 Panthéon-Sorbonne was already a top university in Economics since its inception (benefiting from the faculty of the former University of Paris in this field) but Mercillon also contributed to the development and prestige of the Sorbonne in the emerging field of « Sciences de Gestion » (Management Sciences) with his eminent colleagues at Paris 1 Sorbonne: Pierre Lassègue (the father of Management Studies in France, teaching the first Accounting course at the former University of Paris) but also Marcel Capet, Maurice Flamant, Pierre Moran, Jean-Pierre Jobard, Jean Parent, Nguyen Huu Chau, Robert Goffin, Jacques Wolff, then Max Peyrard, Jean-Pierre Helfer, Colette Rolland, Claire Opsomer, later joined by Mercillon’s disciple, co-author and friend, Pierre Grégory (Art, Management, Marketing), Patrice Poncet (Finance), Jacques Rojot (Organization, Negotiation, HR), Hubert de la Bruslerie (Finance), Alexandre Baetche (Accounting and Marketing), Philippe Raimbourg (Finance), Jean-Emmanuel Ray (Labor Law, HR), etc. Business Administration was previously an exclusive teaching of expensive consular or private business schools (INSEAD, HEC, ESSEC, ESCP,…) in France until public universities (with very low tuition fees) created their own Business Administration departments with not only teaching but also research activities and therefore delivering doctorates in Management. Thanks to Mercillon, his famous colleagues at the Ecole de Management de la Sorbonne (Sorbonne Management School) and their successors, the University of Paris 1 Panthéon-Sorbonne is nowadays the leading research university in the academic field of Business Administration and Management in France, competing with Paris-Dauphine University (formerly Université Paris IX, created in 1968 as an experiment to imitate Harvard Business School, with Dauphine professors originally coming from the « Panthéon » Faculty of Law and Economics of the historical University of Paris).
Luc Chatel, politician and former Minister of France, was one of his students at the Sorbonne. Passionate about arts and museums, Henri Mercillon was also teaching at the Ecole du Louvre and acting as a jury member of the Ecole Nationale d’Administration (ENA)
- Калистратов, Юрий Александрович (Yuriy Alexandrovich Kalistratov, 1899-1973), Russian Professor of the Economics of Cinema, author of « Вопросы экономики советской кинематографии » (1956) and « Экономика производства и обращения кинофильмов в СССР » (1958). He conducted two pioneer and very important studies on the film industry in the USSR in 1958 and 1960. Since 1935, he was the supervisor of the laboratory of feasibility studies at the famous NIKFI (the Soviet Scientific Research Cinema & Photography Institute). In 1943-1945, he taught at the Moscow branch of the Leningrad Institute of Cinema Engineers/LIKI (now the St. Petersburg State University of Film and Television/GUKIT) and in 1946-1948, at the All-Union State Institute of Cinematography/VGIK (now the All-Russian State University of Cinematography or Всероссийский государственный институт кинематографии имени С. А. Герасимова), the world’s oldest film school. Kalistratov‘s work had a great influence on a few economists, including Henri Mercillon.
- Raymond Williams (University of Oxford, University of Cambridge), Welsh Professor of Drama, Culture, Media and Political Science, media critic and author or « Culture and Society » (1958), « Communications » (1962) and « Television: Technology and Cultural form » (1974). Williams extensively wrote about the media (especially about culture, literature, drama, theatre, cinema, radio and most of all television) and is seen as one of the founders of the British field of Cultural Studies with Richard Hoggart and Stuart Hall.
- Michael Conant (UC Berkeley), American Professor Emeritus of Business, author of « Antitrust in the Motion Picture Industry: Economic and Legal Analysis » (1960). Conant‘s work had a great influence on many lawyers and economists, including Henri Mercillon.
- William Baumol (LSE alumnus, Princeton University, New York University), American Professor Emeritus of Economics, author of « Performing Arts – The Economic Dilemma: A Study of Problems Common to Theater, Opera, Music and Dance » (with William Bowen, 1966). Baumol is widely known all around the world for producing the first seminal work in Cultural Economics.
- Guy Debord, French Marxist theorist, writer, filmmaker and poet, who wrote the worldwide best seller « La société du spectacle » in 1967 which is considered to be a catalyst for the Paris uprising and revolts of May 1968. Debord played an influential role among the left-wing protesters (especially at Nanterre and Sorbonne Universities). His Marxist positions criticizing capitalism including the culture industry, consumerism, commodity fetishism, class alienation, mass media and cultural homogenization, are similar to the ones exposed earlier by the Frankfurt School (especially by Theodor W. Adorno, Max Horkheimer and Herbert Marcuse). Debord‘s work had a very important impact on Media Culture, Media Studies, Cultural Studies, Social Theory, Sociology and Philosophy from the 1960s until today.
- Pierre Bourdieu, French Professor of Sociology. After Michel Foucault, Pierre Bourdieu is the second most-cited academic author of books in the humanities in the world. He influenced many sociologists, anthropologists and philosophers around the world, including Anthony Giddens. From 1960, he was the assistant of Raymond Aron at the Université de Paris and secrétaire of the Centre de Sociologie Européenne/CSE founded by Raymond Aron in 1959, from 1964 he taught at the EPHE, in 1968 he created the Centre de Sociologie de l’Education et de la Culture/CSEC, from 1975 he taught at the EHESS, from 1981 at the Collège de France, in 1997 the CSE and the CSEC merged together, in 2010 the new CSE merged with the Centre de Recherches Politiques de la Sorbonne/CRPS founded by Jacques Lagroye to become the Centre Européen de Sociologie et de Science Politique de la Sorbonne/CESSP which therefore became part of the Université de Paris I. Bourdieu is the author of « Le marché des biens symboliques » (1971), « Contribution à une économie des biens symboliques » (1977), »The field of cultural production, or: The economic world reversed » (1983), « L’économie des biens symboliques » (1993-1994), « The economy of symbolic goods » (1998).
- Alan T. Peacock (former LSE), British Composer and Professor of Economics, author of « The Composer in the market place » (with Ronald Weir, 1975), « Cultural Economics and Cultural Policies » (with Ilde Rizzo, 1994) and « The Heritage Game: Economics, Policy, and Practice » (with Ilde Rizzo, 2008). During the 1970s and 1980s, Peacock played a leading role in the field of Cultural Economics.
- Henri Bartoli (co-founder of the Université de Paris I Panthéon-Sorbonne), French Professor Emeritus of Economics, a specialist of Political Economy, the History of Economic Thought, especially in France and in Italy, Labor Economics, Structuralist Economics and Economic Systems, author of « Economie et création collective » (1977), a UNESCO contributor and researcher on (1) Social Economics and Ethics, (2) Development Economics, Globalization and Poverty, and (3) Europe and Culture, international vice-president (1992-2003) of the Société Européenne de Culture/European Society of Culture created in Venice in 1950 (that built bridges between Western Europe and Eastern Europe during the Cold War, maintaining intellectual dialogue between East and West). Bartoli encouraged a new generation of young and brilliant PhD students at the University of Paris 1 Panthéon-Sorbonne to conduct research in the field of Cultural Economics and Economics of the arts, literature and media in the 1970s and 1980s, often acting as their doctoral advisor and supervising their thesis at Paris 1.
- Nadine Toussaint-Desmoulins (Université de Paris II), French Professor Emerita of Media Economics, author of « L’économie des médias » (1978). This book is considered as the first textbook on Media Economics ever written in the world of global academia.
- Bernard Miège (Université de Paris I alumnus, Université de Grenoble III), French Professor Emeritus of Information and Communication Sciences, author of « Capitalisme et industries culturelles » (with Armel Huet, Jacques Ion, Alain Lefèbvre and René Peron, 1978), « Recherches sur la production culturelle marchande et non-marchande : note de présentation de travaux » (1979 doctoral thesis), « The logics at work in the new cultural industries » (1987), « The Capitalization of Cultural Production » (1989), the article « L’Economie politique de la communication » (2004) and the article « Media and Cultural Industries: a Socioeconomic Approach » (2008). Miège is widely seen globally as the founder of the Socio-economic study of the culture and communication industries. In 1978, he co-founded the famous research laboratory GRESEC (Groupe de Recherche sur les Enjeux de la Communication) at the University of Grenoble 3. Bernard Miège influenced other important culture and media academics such as Nicholas Garnham, Philippe Bouquillion and David Hesmondhalgh, as well as the UK government for their own use and definition of the concept of « Cultural Industries » (Pratt, 2008).
- Nicholas Garnham (Université de Paris alumnus, University of Westminster), British Emeritus Professor of Media Studies, author of « Contribution to a Political Economy of Mass Communication » (1979), « The Economics of Television: the UK case » (with Richard Collins and Gareth Locksley, 1988), « Capitalism and Communication: Global Culture and the Economics of Information » (1990), « From the arts to the creative industries: anatomy of a confusion » (2001) and of the article « From Cultural to Creative Industries: An analysis of the implications of the “creative industries” approach to arts and media policy making in the United Kingdom » (2005). A very influential scholar of Media Studies, Garnham was the founding editor of the prestigious journal « Media, Culture and Society » since 1979.
- Patrice Flichy (Université de Paris I alumnus, formerly Stanford University, Université Paris-Est), French Professor of Sociology, author of « Les industries de l’imaginaire. Pour une analyse économique des médias » (1980), « L’imaginaire d’Internet » (2001) and « Le sacre de l’amateur. Sociologie des passions ordinaires à l’ère numérique » (2010)
- Jean Baudrillard (Université de Paris alumnus), French sociologist, philosopher, cultural theorist, political commentator and photographer, frequently associated with postmodernism and specifically post-structuralism, is one of the most emblematic writers of the French Theory that influenced many American and British academics from departments of Humanities and Social Sciences in US and UK universities in the 1970s and 1980s which led to the creation of Cultural Studies, Postcolonial Studies and Gender Studies. Baudrillard is the author of the very influential book in the fields of Social Sciences and Humanities « Simulacres et simulation » (1981).
- Xavier Greffe (Université de Paris I), French Professor of Cultural Economics and Economics of the arts, literature and culture, author of the influential « Analyse économique de la bureaucratie » (1981), « Socio-économie de la culture. Livre, Musique » (with François Rouet and Sylvie Pflieger, 1990) and « La politique culturelle en France » (with Sylvie Pflieger, 2015)
- René Bonnell (Université de Paris I alumnus), senior executive of the French film industry (Gaumont, Canal+, France Télévisions), film distributor, producer and author of « L’Initiative culturelle en économie de marché: l’exemple du cinéma français depuis 1945 » (1976 doctoral thesis at Paris 1) and « Le financement de la production et de la distribution cinématographiques à l’heure du numérique » (2013)
- Wladimir Andreff (Université de Paris I), French Professor Emeritus of Economics, author of « Economie du sport » (1986), « Handbook on the Economics of Sport » (editor with Stefan Szymanski, 2009), « Economie internationale du sport » (2010) and « Mondialisation économique du sport. Manuel de référence en économie du sport » (2012). Andreff was President of the French Economic Association (Association Française de Science Economique/AFSE), of the International Association of Sport Economists/IASE and of the European Association for Comparative Economic Studies/EACES.
- Dominique Leroy (Université de Paris I), French Professor Emeritus of Economics, author of « Economie des arts du spectacle vivant : Essai sur la relation entre l’économique et l’esthétique » (1977 doctoral thesis at Paris 1), « Histoire des arts du spectacle en France: aspects économiques, politiques et esthétiques de la Renaissance à la Première Guerre mondiale » (1990), « Hommage à Henri Bartoli » (2011). Leroy has been the chosen successor of Henri Bartoli at the head of the European Society of Culture’s French Center.
- Pierre-Michel Menger (Collège de France), French Professor of Sociology, author of « Le Paradoxe du musicien : le compositeur, le mélomane et l’État dans la société contemporaine » (1983), « Portrait de l’artiste en travailleur. Métamorphoses du capitalisme » (2003), « Le travail créateur. S’accomplir dans l’incertain » (2009) and « The Economics of Creativity. Art and Achievement Under Uncertainty » (2014)
- Alain Herscovici (Université de Paris I alumnus, Universidade Federal do Espírito Santo), French Professor of Cultural Economics, author of « Essai sur l’économie de la musique moderne » (1983 doctoral thesis at Paris 1) and « Economie de la culture et de la communication: Elements pour une analyse socio-economique de la culture dans le capitalisme avancé » (1994)
- Alain Busson (Université de Paris I alumnus, HEC Paris), French Professor Emeritus of Media Economics and Economy of the Cultural and Creative Industries, author of « La place du théâtre dans le champ culturel. De l’influence de l’économique sur les choix esthétiques » (1983 doctoral thesis at Paris 1), « Le théâtre en France » (1986), « Portraits économiques de la culture » (with Yves Evrad, 1987), « Le management des entreprises artistiques et culturelles » (with Y. Evrard, C. Cauvin, E. Chiapello, N. Ferry-Maccario, A. Hadida, A. Keravel, O. Silhol, 1993), « Les industries culturelles et créatives – Economie et stratégie » (with Yves Evrard, 2013) and editor of « Management des industries culturelles et créatives » (with Yves Evrard, 2015).
- Alain Le Diberder (Université de Paris I alumnus), French senior executive of the television industry (France Télévisions, Canal+, AlloCiné, Arte), author of « La formation du profit dans les industries culturelles » (1985) and « Révolution numérique et industries culturelles » (with Philippe Chantepie, 2005)
- Françoise Benhamou (Université de Paris I), French Professor of Cultural Economics, author of « Essai d’analyse économique d’une pratique culturelle: l’achat et la lecture de livres » (1985 doctoral thesis at Paris 1), « L’économie de la culture » (1996), « Les galeries d’art contemporain en France. Portrait et enjeux face à la mondialisation » (with Dominique Sagot-Duvauroux and Nathalie Moureau, 2001), « L’économie du star system » (2002), « Les dérèglements de l’exception culturelle : Plaidoyer pour une perspective européenne » (2006), « Droit d’auteur et copyright » (with Joëlle Farchy, 2007), « Économie du patrimoine culturel » (2012), »Le Livre à l’heure numérique : papier, écrans, vers un nouveau vagabondage » (2014) and « Politique culturelle : fin de partie ou nouvelle saison ? » (2015)
- Dominique Sagot-Duvauroux (Université de Paris I alumnus, Université d’Angers), French Professor of Cultural Economics, author of « Structure de financement et organisation d’un système, l’exemple du théâtre » (1985 doctoral thesis at Paris 1), « Le Marché de l’art contemporain en France, prix et stratégies » (with Bernard Rouget and Sylvie Pflieger, 1991) and « Le Marché de l’art contemporain » (with Nathalie Moureau, 2006)
- Enrique Bustamente (Universidad Complutense de Madrid), Spanish Professor of Information and Communication Sciences, author of « Las industrias culturales en España » (1986) and editor of « Industrias creativas. Amenazas sobre la cultura digital » (2011)
- Robert G. Picard (University of Oxford, Harvard University, Yale University), American academic expert on Media Economics, Media Management and Media Regulation, author of « Media Economics: Concepts and Issues » (1989)
- Bruno Frey (University of Basel), Swiss Professor of Economics and Political Economy, author of « Muses and Markets. Explorations in the Economics of the Arts » (with Walter Pommerehne, 1989)
- Joelle Farchy (Université de Paris I), French Professor of Cultural Economics and Information and Communication Sciences, author of « Le Cinéma français sous influence: de la concurrence audiovisuelle à la différentiation des produits cinématographiques » (1989 doctoral thesis at Paris 1), « Le cinéma déchaîné. Mutation d’une industrie » (1992), « Économie des politiques culturelles » (with Dominique Sagot-Duvauroux, 1994), « Internet et le droit d’auteur, la culture Napster » (2003), « L’industrie du cinéma » (2004), « Les enjeux de la mondialisation culturelle » (with Jean Tardif, 2006) and « Droit d’auteur et copyright » (with Françoise Benhamou, 2007)
- Gaëtan Tremblay (UQAM), Canadian Professor of Information and Communication Sciences, who published « Les Industries de la culture et de la communication au Québec et au Canada » (editor, 1990)
- Mario d’Angelo (formerly Université de Paris IV), French Professor of Creative Industries and Strategy, Music Business, Culture and Management, author of « La Renaissance du disque. Les mutations mondiales d’une industrie culturelle » (1990) and « Socio-économie de la musique en France. Diagnostic d’un système vunérable » (1997)
- Pierre Kopp (Université de Paris I), French Professor of Law and Economics, author of « Télévisions en concurrence » (1990)
- Philippe Bouquillion* (Université de Paris XIII and Université de Paris VIII), French Professor of Information and Communication Sciences, who published the article « Le spectacle vivant : de l’économie administrée à la marchandisation » (1992), the article « Livre et musique enregistrée sur Internet : quelques enjeux empiriques et théoriques » (2001), the article « The formation of Cultural and Communication Industry Poles : between financial coups and the integration of industrial production lines » (2005), « Les industries de la culture et de la communication en mutation » (editor with Combès, 2007), the article « Les industries de la culture face aux industries de la communication : l’actualité des théories des industries culturelles » (2008), « Les industries de la culture et de la communication. Les stratégies du capitalisme » (2008), « Le Web collaboratif. Mutations des industries culturelles » (with Jacob Matthews, 2010), « Diversité et Industries culturelles » (editor with Combès, 2011), « Creative Economy, Creative Industries : des notions à traduire » (editor, 2012) and the article « Francophone Perspectives on Creative Industries and the Creative Economy » (2014). Philippe Bouquillion is an eminent researcher at the famous LabSIC (Laboratoire des Sciences de l’Information et de la Communication), Research Center for Information and Communication Sciences of the University of Paris 13.
I consider Bouquillion as the intellectual successor of the most prominent French scholar of the cultural and creative industries, Bernard Miège.
- Ruth Towse (LSE alumna, former LSE, Bournemouth University, Erasmus University Rotterdam), British Professor Emerita of Economics of Creative Industries, Cultural Economics and Economics of Copyright, author of « Singers in the Marketplace: The Economics of the Singing Profession » (with Claus Moser, 1993), « A Handbook of Cultural Economics » (2003), « The Internet and the Mass Media » (with Lucy Küng and Robert G. Picard, 2008), « A Textbook of Cultural Economics » (2010), « Handbook on the Digital Creative Economy » (2013), « Advanced Introduction to Cultural Economics » (2014)
- Scott Lash (LSE alumnus, Goldsmiths), American Professor of Sociology and Cultural Studies, author of « Economies of Signs and Space » (with John Urry, 1994) and « Global Culture Industry: The Mediation of Things » (with Celia Lury, 2007)
- David Throsby (LSE alumnus, Macquarie University), Australian Distinguished Professor of Cultural Economics, author of « The Production and Consumption of the Arts: A View of Cultural Economics » (1994), « Economics and Culture » (2001) and « The Economics of Cultural Policy » (2010)
- Laurent Creton (Université de Paris III), French Professor of Information and Communication Sciences, author of « Économie du cinéma. Perspectives stratégiques » (1994), « Cinéma et marché » (1997) and « L’économie du cinéma » (2003)
- Nathalie Sonnac (Université de Paris I alumna, Université de Paris II), French Professor of Information and Communication Sciences, author of « L’économie de la presse » (with Patrick Le Floch, 2000) and « L’industrie des médias » (with Jean Gabszewicz, 2006)
- Richard Caves (Harvard University), American Professor Emeritus of Economics, author of « Creative Industries: Contracts Between Art & Commerce » (2000)
- Fabrice Rochelandet (Université de Paris I alumnus, Université de Paris III), French Professor of Cultural Economics, Digital Media Economics and Regulation of the Digital Economy author of « Propriété intellectuelle et changement technologique, la mise en oeuvre du droit d’auteur dans les industries culturelles » (2000 doctoral thesis at Paris 1) and « Economie des arts et de la culture » (with François Mairesse, 2015)
- Gilles Le Blanc* (former LSE, Université de Paris I, Mines ParisTech), French Professor of Industrial Economics, Innovation and Digital Economics (especially the digital distribution of creative content and cultural products online), author of « Market Efficiency in the Digital Economy: Lessons from the US and European Telecom Industry Dynamics » (2001), « Modem Le Maudit : Economie de la distribution numérique des contenus » (with Olivier Bomsel and Anne-Gaëlle Geffroy, 2006) and « When Internet Meets Entertainment : The Economics of Digital Media Industries » (with Olivier Bomsel and Anne-Gaëlle Geffroy, 2006). Le Blanc was teaching in the Master « Stratégies industrielles et politiques publiques de défense » (University of Paris 1 Panthéon-Sorbonne and French Ministry of Defense) and was also the director of CERNA, the famous Research Center of Industrial Economics of the engineering school Ecole des Mines de Paris (the school of Maurice Allais, one of the only three French economists to have ever received the Nobel Prize in Economics, and of two prominent scholars of the sociology of science, technology and society (STS), Bruno Latour and Michel Callon who developed the famous actor-network theory (ANT) at the Centre de Sociologie de l’Innovation (CSI) of the Ecole des Mines de Paris).
*I had the chance to interview Gilles Le Blanc (†) and Philippe Bouquillion in 2008 for my Master’s thesis at the LSE.
- Richard Florida (University of Toronto), American Professor of Urban Studies, author of « The Rise of the Creative Class » (2002)
- John Howkins (University of Lincoln, Shanghai Theatre Academy), British author and speaker on the Creative Industries, who wrote « The Creative Economy: How People Make Money from Ideas » (2002)
- Philippe Le Guern (formerly Université de Paris I, Université de Nantes), French Professor of Communication and Culture, and Sociomusicology (the sociology of music), editor of « Les cultes médiatiques. Culture fan et oeuvres cultes » (2002) and « Stéréo. Sociologie comparée des musiques populaires en France et en Grande-Bretagne » (2008)
- Stuart Cunningham (Queensland University of Technology), Australian Professor of Media and Communications, author of the article « From cultural to creative industries: Theory, industry, and policy implications » (2002)
- David Hesmondhalgh (University of Leeds), British Professor of Media, Music and Culture, author of « The Cultural Industries » (2002, 2007, 2012)
- Andy Pratt (former LSE, City University London), British Professor of Cultural Economy, author of the article « Cultural Industries and Cultural Policy » (with Hesmondhalgh, 2005) and the article « Cultural commodity chains, cultural clusters, or cultural production chains? » (2008)
- Henry Jenkins (University of Southern California), American Provost Professor of Communication, Journalism and Cinematic Arts, author of « Convergence Culture: Where Old and New Media Collide » (2006)
- François Moreau (Université de Paris I alumnus, Université de Paris XIII), French Professor of Economics, author of « L’Industrie du disque » (with Nicolas Curien, 2006)
- Victor Ginsburgh (Université Libre de Bruxelles, Université Catholique de Louvain), Belgian Professor of Economics, author of « The Handbook of the Economics of Art and Culture » (with David Throsby, 2006)
- Eric Brousseau (formerly Université de Paris I, Université Paris-Dauphine), French Professor of Economics and Management, author of « Internet and Digital Economics: Principles, Methods and Applications » (with Nicolas Curien, 2007)
- Chris Bilton (University of Warwick), British Professor of Cultural Policy, author of « Management and Creativity: from creative industries to creative management » (2007)
- Ghislain Deslandes (Université de Paris I alumnus, ESCP Europe), French Professor of Media Management, author of « Le management des médias » (2008)
- Thomas Paris (HEC Paris), French Professor of Creativity and Innovation Management, author of the article « Des industries culturelles aux industries créatives: un changement de paradigme salutaire ? » (2010) and of « Manager la créativité – Innover en s’inspirant de Pixar, Ducasse, Les ateliers Jean Nouvel, Hermès… » (2010)
- Pierre Moeglin (Université de Paris XIII, Institut Universitaire de France), French Professor of Information and Communication Sciences, author of the article « La question des industries créatives en France » (with Bernard Miège and Philippe Bouquillion, 2010) and « L’industrialisation des biens symboliques. Les industries créatives en regard des industries culturelles » (with Bernard Miège and Philippe Bouquillion, 2013)
- Jean-Guy Lacroix (UQAM), Canadian Professor of the Sociology of Culture, Information and Communication
- Yolande Combès (Université de Paris XIII), French Professor Emerita of Information and Communication Sciences
- Tristan Mattelart (Université de Paris VIII), French Professor of International Communication
- Claude Forest (Université de Paris III), French Professor of the Economics of Cinema
- Franck Rebillard (Université de Paris III), French Professor of Information and Communication Sciences
- Bruno Latour (LSE, Sciences Po Paris), French philosopher and Professor of the Sociology of Science, Innovation and Technology
- Sonia Livingstone (LSE), British Professor of Social Psychology, Media and Everyday Life, Media Audiences and Media Literacy
- Leslie Haddon (LSE), British Senior Researcher/Lecturer on the Consumption, Domestication and Social Shaping of ICTs
- Robin Mansell (LSE), Canadian Professor of New Media and the Internet, LSE Deputy Director and Provost
- Nick Couldry (LSE), British Professor of Media and Communications, Culture and Power, and Social Theory
- Terhi Rantanen (LSE), Finnish Professor of Global Media and Communications, Globalization, Media History, Media and Democracy
- Bingchun Meng (LSE), Chinese Associate Professor of Political Economy of Media Industries and of Chinese media in the global era
- Damian Tambini (LSE), British Associate Professor of Media and Communications Regulation and Policy, Intellectual Property
- Daniel Sabatier (Université de Paris I), French Professor of Legal History and Media Law. Sabatier was the founder and former Director of the Sorbonne Master in Audiovisual Law, Economics and Management until his retirement.
- Patrick Eveno (Université de Paris I), French Professor of Media History. Eveno is the Director of the Sorbonne Master in Knowledge Communication and Technologies and Information Management.
- Bernard Darras (Université de Paris I), French Professor of Semiotics, Aesthetics, Visual Arts, Sciences of Art and Cultural Mediation. Darras is the Director of the Sorbonne Master in Interactive Multimedia.
- Pierre Sirinelli (Université de Paris I), French Professor of Intellectual Property Law and Copyright. Sirinelli is the Director of the Sorbonne Master in Audiovisual Law, Economics and Management.
- Frédéric Sojcher (Université de Paris I), Belgian film director, screenwriter, film critic and Professor of Arts, Cinema and Film studies, expert on the economics of cinema, film creation, production and distribution. Author of « Le cinema belge et l’Europe. Institutions et identités culturelles » (1996 doctoral thesis at Paris 1 supervised by Henri Mercillon), « The Economics of Cinema: History, Strategic Choices and Cultural Policy » (2002). Sojcher is the Director of the Sorbonne Master in Film Screenwriting, Direction and Production.
- Jean-Noël Kapferer (Université de Paris I alumnus, HEC Paris, Tsinghua University), French Emeritus Professor of Management, Marketing, Branding, Communication and expert on Strategic Brand Management, Prestige Brands and Luxury Management
- Jean-Marc Lehu (Université de Paris I), French Associate Professor of Management, Marketing, Branding, Communication and expert on Brand Strategy, Customer Relationship, Customer Loyalty, Product Placement, Celebrity Endorsement and Branded Entertainment. Lehu is the prolific author of « Origines, fondements et modes d’utilisation des celebrités par la publicité » (1993 doctoral thesis at Paris 1 supervised by Pierre Grégory), « Stratégiesdemarque.com – Concevoir, protéger, gérer la marque sur l’Internet » (2001), « Stratégie de fidélisation » (2003), « L’encyclopédie du Marketing » (2004), « La publicité est dans le film : Placement de produits et stratégie de marque au cinéma, dans les chansons, dans les jeux vidéo » (2006), « Brand Rejuvenation: How to Protect, Strengthen & Add Value to Your Brand to Prevent It from Ageing » (2006), « Branded Entertainment: Product Placement and Brand Strategy in the Entertainment Business » (2007) and editor of « MBA Marketing » (2011). Lehu is the Director of the Sorbonne Master in Logistics, Marketing and Distribution.
Along with Alfonso Puyal Sanz (Complutense), Leslie Haddon (LSE) and Ricardo de Cala Castillo (Complutense), Jean-marc Lehu (Sorbonne) played an important part in my choice to dedicate my life to audiovisual, communication, marketing, media and technology.
6/6 – Conclusion: the Creative Industries and Digitalization
Obviously one cannot manage an artist, a record label, a radio station, a TV channel or a fashion house like a car manufacturing company.
Managing individuals and organizations designing, producing and distributing cultural products and symbolic goods requires a very particular knowledge. Moreover, even though the cultural and creative sectors share some great similarities, each of them also has its own characteristics to master.
As UNESCO and many British professionals and politicians consider the cultural industries to be a subset of the creative industries, and also because of the rapidly expanding digital disruption of the creative economy, the concept of the « Cultural and Creative Industries » has been progressively replaced in the UK by the new popular concept of the « Creative and Digital Industries« . The cities of London, Sheffield, Manchester, Bolton, Liverpool, Bradford and Leeds, just to name a few, have local hubs dedicated to the Creative and Digital Industries to encourage the fusion between creativity and digital, to attract investments and to foster innovation and growth.
Although many people wrongly believe that the digital transition is over, this is actually just the beginning of the digital revolution and the creative economy will have to adapt to the next innovations disrupting markets, business models, processes, products and services such as SMACS (social, mobile, analytics, cloud, cybersecurity), virtualization, NFC/RFID, 3D printers, drones, robotics, AI (Artificial Intelligence), augmented reality, virtual reality, connected objects/smart devices enabled by IoT (the Internet of Things), Semantic Web and Web 3.0.
According to the McKinsey Global Institute (MGI) Industry Digitization Index (which combines dozens of indicators providing a comprehensive picture of where and how companies are building digital assets, expanding digital usage, and creating a more digital workforce, the first major attempt to measure digital progress and adoption in each sector) first published in December 2015 and in the Harvard Business Review in April 2016, the Information and Communications Technology (ICT) sector, the Media sector and Professional Services (like Consulting) are the three most digitally advanced (‘digitized’ or ‘digitalized’) sectors in the US economy. By the way, I have been working in these three sectors.
Gartner defines ‘digitization’ as: « the process of changing from analog to digital form. » and ‘digitalization’ as « the use of digital technologies to change a business model and provide new revenue and value-producing opportunities; it is the process of moving to a digital business. »
In addition, the 2015 Digital Business Global Executive Study and Research Project by MIT Sloan Management Review and Deloitte identifies Strategy as the key driver in the digital arena: « Strategy, not Technology, Drives Digital Transformation« . Download the full study in PDF: here.
Based on these concrete paradigm shifts in today’s real world and the theoretical framework that I previously drafted here, one could easily understand why I did not follow standard management studies at a business school or classical science studies at an engineering school. I rather chose to study International Strategy, International Economics, International Management, International Marketing, Global Brand Strategy and International Business Law at the Université de Paris I Panthéon-Sorbonne (Paris 1) and Global Studies, International Communication, Media Studies, Sociology, Digital Sociology, the Sociology of the Internet, the Social Shaping of Technology and the Domestication of ICTs at the London School of Economics and Political Science (LSE) to gain an essential, critical and deep pluridisciplinary understanding of the cultural and creative industries, digitalization and globalization.